Friday, May 17, 2024
HomeEditor PicksWhy Is The Gospel Of Thomas Not In The Bible

Why Is The Gospel Of Thomas Not In The Bible

The Key Criteria For Canonicity: Apostolicity

Gospel of Thomas: Why Is It Not In the Bible?

The reason that there are only four gospels in the New Testament is because these were the only first century gospels available to the early Church, as far as scholars can currently tell, that were written either by an apostle or an associate of an apostle. Though each of the New Testament Gospels was written anonymously, there was a strong tradition connecting each of them to apostles or associates of apostles . An apostle was someone who knew the historical Jesus or had seen an appearance of the risen Jesus .

Is The Gospel Of Thomas Real Or Fake

Wayne Jackson

The e-mail I received was from Dr. Paterson Brown, who is affiliated with the Ecumenical Coptic Project in Athens, Greece. He forwarded to me copies of the so-called Coptic Gospels of Thomas, Phillip, and Truth.With reference to the Gospel of Thomas, Dr. Brown wrote:

Significantly, Professor Helmut Koester of Harvard University, speaking as President of the Society of Biblical Literature , has declared that nearly all biblical scholars in the United States agree that Thomas is as authentic as the New Testament Gospels.

Authentic? In what sense? Certainly not authentic in the sense that the Gospel of Thomas carries the same credibility as the canonical Gospel records: Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John.

There is considerable evidence that the document that is called the Gospel of Thomas was not authored by the apostle who bore that name.

What are the facts relative to this ancient text that has caused such a sensation in recent years?

Acts : 13 When They Saw The Boldness Of Peter

King James Bible Now when they saw the boldness of Peter and John, and perceived that they were unlearned and ignorant men, they marvelled and they took knowledge of them, that they had been with Jesus. New King James Version Now when they saw the boldness of Peter and John, and perceived that they were uneducated and untrained men, they marveled.

Recommended Reading: Who Said Pray Without Ceasing

The Case For A Second

1. Dependence on the 1st Century New Testament Writings

First, the Gospel of Thomas shows dependence on the first century New Testament writings, even parts of the Gospel of Mark that were edited by Matthew and Luke.1The view that Matthew and Luke used Mark in the composition of their Gospels is known as Markan Priority. While some scholars debate whether this is true, the majority of scholars, both liberal and conservative, hold to Markan Priority. Craig Evans notes that the Gospel of Thomas quotes or alludes to more than half of the New Testament writings including Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, Acts, Romans, 1-2 Corinthians, Galatians, Ephesians, Colossians, 1 Thessalonians, 1 Timothy, Hebrews, 1 John, and Revelation.2For just one example, see how saying 17 reflects 1 Cor. 2:9. This dependence indicates that the Gospel of Thomas was probably written sometime in the second century, especially since its references include later first century works such as the Gospel of John and Revelation. Evans notes, Im now aware of a Christian writing prior to AD 150 that references this much of the New Testament .3Interview with Craig Evans, in Lee Strobel, The Case for the Real Jesus, Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2007, p. 36. For example, the Epistles of Ignatius, which were written around A.D. 110, do not quote half as much material as Thomas does.

2. Possible 2nd Century Syrian Influence

3. Lack of References from Early Church Fathers or First Century Witnesses

Supernatural Precocious And Vengeful

Dead Sea Scrolls Gospel Of Thomas

The text within these stories intends to tell the story of Jesus from the ages of 5 to 12. The stories have fanciful and supernatural events, which at once prove the divinity of Christ and display bizarre behaviors in comparison to the canonical Gospels. In the stories, Jesus is showcased as a precocious child who was pursuing his education early.

The story also covers how Jesus as a child matured, and learned how to use his powers for good. There are instances mentioned within the Gospel that stated how people around him first feared and rejected him, but later showed admiration.

One of the earliest stories tells of a child who spills water collected by the infant Jesus. Rather than showing the compassion and mercy so familiar in canonical scripture, Jesus strikes the child down, killing him with his supernatural powers. He later kills another child in the same way, simply because he bumped into him.

Following that, one of the episodes or stories had Jesus making birds out of clay, trying to blow life into them. This act appears elsewhere in other holy texts, most notably in the Quran .

Jesus brings clay birds to life

Many of the stories show extreme manifestations of the divine powers attributed to Jesus. There are stories of how Jesus helped resurrect a friend from the dead who fell off the roof, and helped his friend who cut off his foot while using an axe. Another story recounts how Jesus healed his brother of a venomous snake bite.

Don’t Miss: Chesapeake Bible College And Seminary

Why Isnt The Gospel Of Barnabas Part Of The Christian Cannon

So to me its clear why the Gospel of Barnabas isnt accepted by Christians as part of our Cannon Its not written by an apostle. Its contrary to orthodox thought. Its likely written over 1400 years after the fact.

The question for me is How do Muslims handle the tension between the Quran and the Gospel of Barnabas?

Thanks for your question. I learned a lot. I hope I havent offended you with my response. I would very much like to hear your response to this article.

Peter Preaches The Simple Gospel

The Apostle Peter simply told the Good News of Christ crucified on the cross for our sins, buried and risen three days later. When Cornelius believed, he was immediately saved. This is the childlike faith which brings eternal life. The way to be saved is not to DO, but to BELIEVE! That is, make it your own.

Also Check: What Does The Bible Say About Eating Fat

Beware Of Secret Sayings

Thomas consists of a collection of 114 sayings of Jesus, that are supposed to be a secret revelation the Lord gave to the apostle Thomas. That secret business itself ought to be a red flag!

Some of these sayings repeat the words of Christ from the canonical Gospel accounts. About forty of them are entirely new. Most scholars believe that the Gospel of Thomas is significantly contaminated with the ancient heretical philosophy known as Gnosticism .

Why Was The Book Of Thomas Not Included In The Bible

The Gospel of Thomas – Why is it not in the Bible?

Gospel of ThomasThomas

. Subsequently, one may also ask, why did they remove books from the Bible?

The only time books were removed from the Bible happened during the Protestant Reformation. After Martin Luther was excommunicated from the Roman Catholic Church he questioned which books were supposed to be part of the Biblical canon.

Subsequently, question is, why is the Gospel of Thomas important? The Gospel of Thomas is important for three reasons: As an another answer mentioned, Thomas is a sayings gospel. The gospel of Thomas is very clearly a second-century Gnostic writing. The Gospel of Thomas provides a valuable insight into second-century Christian Gnosticism.

Also know, why were some Gospels left out of the Bible?

The texts might only have been known to few people, or they might have been left out because their content does not fit well into that of the other books of the Bible. Some of the apocrypha were written at a later date, and were therefore not included. The Authorized King James Version called these books ‘Apocrypha’.

What books did not make it into the Bible?

10 Books Not Included in the New Testament

  • Apocalypse of Peter.

Also Check: Omer Definition Bible

Moon Gods And Goddesses From World Mythology

Although the evidence of four manuscripts is rather limited to make any grand claims, it is very possible that the Gospel of Thomas Origen knew and referenced was not particularly similar to the later Coptic version, which would explain his cautious acceptance of portions of Thomas against the more wholesale rejection of later writers .

The Nag Hammadi Codex

The fourth century Coptic manuscript was found as a part of a collection of primarily gnostic works collectively known as the Nag-Hammadi Library.6 It contains 114 sayings, one of which appears to have been added sometime after the initial Codex was written7.

Although some scholars argue that portions of the Gospel of Thomas date to the mid-1st century, the text of this Coptic version cannot date any earlier than the latter half of the second century. It puts forward a form of pure Gnosticism which had not evolved until well into the second century and is reflective of the Valentinian Gnostic texts with which it was found. What is more, this text shows a reliance on the synoptic gospels and perhaps even Pauls epistles8. The writer of this particular Nag Hammadi Codex seems to have drawn from multiple gospels and, when two gospels present a different wording, he deliberately chose the parallel that could most easily be understood in a Gnostic sense5.

Gospel of Thomas fragment P.Oxy 655

The Lost Books Of The Bible: The Lost Gospel According To

The Lost Books of the Bible, , at p. 282. THE LOST GOSPEL ACCORDING TO PETER [In the valley of the Upper Nile, on the right bank of the river, is the mysterious town of Akhmîm. It was called Panopolis in ancient times when it was the capital of the district. The remnants of monasteries and the ruins of temples mark the …

Read Also: Maryland Bible College & Seminary Baltimore Md

Jesus In The Gospel Of Thomas

Man of Sorrows by Andrea Mantegna

Professor Elaine H. Pagels told PBS: The Jesus of the Gospel of Thomas does appear rather different from the Jesus we encounter in the others. Because the Gospel of Mark, for example, depicts Jesus as an utterly unique being. This is the good news of Jesus of Nazareth, the Son of God. The Gospel of John says that Jesus isn’t even a human being at all, but he’s a divine presence who comes down to heaven in human shape…. The Gospel of John says, “God sent his son into the world to save the world.” If you believe in him, you’re saved, if you don’t believe in him you’re already damned, because you haven’t believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God.

Now, , this Jesus comes to reveal that you and he are, if you like, twins…. And what you discover as you read the Gospel of Thomas, which you’re meant to discover, is that you and Jesus at a deep level are identical twins. And that you discover that you are the child of God just as he is. And so that at the end of the gospel Jesus speaks to Thomas and says, “Whoever drinks from my mouth will become as I am, and I will become that person, and the mysteries will be revealed to him.” Here, Jesus does not take the role of authority and teacher.

Gospel Of Jesus’s Wife

What is the Gospel of Thomas and why is it not in the Bible?

Gospel of Jesus’ Wife

In 2015, a business card-sized fragment written in Coptic which contained a translated line that said “Jesus said to them, ‘My wife ‘” and also referred to a “Mary,” possibly Mary Magdalene was touted as part a long-lost, potentially earth-shattering gospel, dubbed the Gospel of Jesus’s Wife, that appeared to imply that possibly Jesus was married. Karen King, a professor at Harvard Divinity School, first announced the discovery of the so-called Gospel of Jesus’s Wife in September 2012. King said the papyrus didnt prove that Jesus himself was actually married, but rather that some people, who lived after Jesus’ time, believed he was.

Owen Jarus wrote in Live Science, Radiocarbon dating indicates that the papyrus dates to around A.D. 800, and tests on the papyrus’s ink confirm that it could have been created at that time. Based on these findings, King and a few other scholars have argued that the text is authentic, as it could be a copy of a text written in earlier times. However, a number of scholars have noted peculiar features of the “gospel’s” writing that suggest it is a modern forgery one possibly based off a text that first appeared online in 1997. /~/

Read Also: Maryland Bible College & Seminary

Summary Question 17 What Is The Gospel Of Thomas

After the New Testament period, there were a number of works that arose that claimed to have been written by someone who was mentioned in the New Testament. However, the works are nothing but forgeries. Among other things, these forgeries are known as the New Testament Pseudepigrapha. There are a number of gospels, acts, letters, and apocalypses that use the name of a biblical character as its author. Yet that person did not write the particular work that has his name on it.

One of the most prominent of these forgeries is the Gospel of Thomas. This work is supposedly a number of secret sayings of Jesus that are recorded by the disciple Thomas. Yet there is no evidence whatsoever of their authenticity.

On the contrary, the Gospel of Thomas fails for a number of reasons.

First, the approach is secret rather than the open approach of the gospels. Jesus emphasized that those who follow Him should publicly proclaim His teachings. The Gospel of Thomas on the other hand speaks of secret knowledge about Jesus. The contrast could not be greater.

In addition, there is no historical setting for these supposed sayings of Jesus. They are merely a group of sayings with no context to them. We do not know when or where Jesus supposedly said them. Contrast this to the gospels where the sayings of Jesus are always placed in some historical context.

Why Was The Infancy Gospel Of Thomas Excluded From The Bible

When the first widespread attempts were made to define the Catholic biblical canon in the 3rd and 4th centuries AD, the compilers had many texts to choose from, and had to be selective in confirming which were included. Many stories of the life of Jesus were ultimately classed as non-canon, for a variety of reasons. But perhaps none were as strange as the Infancy Gospel of Thomas.

In its most simple terms, this gospel is a collection of Jesuss childhood stories, filling a useful gap within the canonical gospels. It might seem therefore to be a useful addition to the existing canon.

Within the New Testament, the Gospel of Luke contains the only significant information on the childhood Jesus, which featured 12-year old Jesus and his parents. It is mentioned in Luke 2:41-52.

So, why was it excluded?

Recommended Reading: What Does God Say About Being Lonely

Is The Gospel Of Thomas A Gnostic Gospel

Gnostic Christian literature

The Gospel of Thomas, preserved in a Coptic gnostic library found about 1945 in Egypt, contains several such sayings, besides some independent versions of canonical sayings. At certain points the Gospel tradition finds independent confirmation in the letters of the Apostle Paul.

Karen King Admits Gospel Of Jesus’s Wife Probably A Forgery

The Gospel of Thomas, Explained! (Why It’s Not in the Bible)

Karen King

In 2016, Harvard scholar Karen L. King admitted that the Gospel of Jesuss Wife papyrus is probably a forgery. Ariel Sabar wrote in The Atlantic, For four years, King has defended the so-called Gospel of Jesuss Wife against scholars who argued it was a forgery. But Thursday, for the first time, King said the papyruswhich she introduced to the world in 2012is a probable fake. She reached this conclusion, she said, after reading The Atlantics investigation into the papyruss origins, which appears in the magazines July/August issue and was posted to its website. It tips the balance towards forgery, she said.

Critics had argued for years that errors in Coptic grammar, similarities with the Gospel of Thomas, and other problems pointed to forgery. But King had placed her faith in the opinions of expert papyrologists, along with a series of carbon-dating and other scientific tests, at MIT, Harvard, and Columbia, that had turned up no signs of modern tampering or forgery. When I called her in March while reporting my Atlantic story, she said she was not interested in commenting onor even hearing aboutmy findings before publication. Thursday afternoon, however, she called me to say the story was fascinating and very helpful. |+|

Don’t Miss: Bible Verses To Read When Lonely

The Theology Of The Gospel Of Thomas

As mentioned before, the Gospel of Thomas deeply reflects the theology of the collection in which it was found. Just as the Valentinian Exposition presents itself as a mystery only for the enlightened few, the Gospel of Thomas opens with a claim to containing the secret sayings, of a Jesus who announces, “I disclose my mysteries to those of mysteries.* This characteristic trait of a secret knowledge gnosis has lent its name to a diverse group of sects collectively known as the Gnostics.

Although Christian Gnostic sects varied greatly in their teachings, emphasizing an esoteric wisdom over objective truths, they did possess certain similarities secret revelation, esoteric wisdom as a means of salvation, and a rejection of the Old Testament God as a lesser, if not evil, deity9.

The Gnosis of Thomas Compared to Other Christian Writings

The Gospel of Thomas exhibits a theology of salvation by gnosis from the very first saying, claiming said, Whoever discovers the interpretation of these sayings will not taste death. The Jesus of the Gospel of Thomas speaks in vagaries, asserting that, The kingdom is within you and it is outside you. When you know yourselves, then you will be known, and you will understand that you are children of the living Father.

You are being hoisted up by Jesus Christ, as with a crane , while the rope you use is the Holy Spirit. Your faith is what lifts you up, while love is the way you ascend to God.11


Most Popular